Two Friends Disagreeing About a Mutual Friend

Explore engaging examples of two friends in disagreement over a mutual friend, sparking creativity in your writing.
By Alex

Examples of Two Friends Having a Disagreement About a Mutual Friend

Example 1: The Birthday Bash

In this scenario, two friends, Sarah and Jake, are planning a surprise birthday party for their mutual friend, Lily. However, they have conflicting ideas about how to celebrate her special day. This disagreement reveals their differing priorities and personalities, making it a relatable situation for many readers.

“I really think we should go all out with the decorations! I mean, it’s Lily’s 30th birthday!” Sarah exclaimed, her eyes sparkling with excitement as she flipped through colorful party supply catalogs. “She deserves a grand celebration, something she’ll never forget!”

Jake, however, furrowed his brow, leaning back in his chair. “But Sarah, you know how Lily is. She hates being the center of attention. I think a simple dinner with close friends would mean more to her. We shouldn’t overwhelm her with a big party.”

Sarah crossed her arms, frustration creeping into her voice. “But if we don’t do something big, she might think we don’t care! This is a milestone birthday!”

Jake sighed, clearly exasperated. “It’s not about the size of the celebration; it’s about making her feel loved. I just want to do what’s best for her.”

This disagreement showcases how friends can have different interpretations of what their mutual friend would appreciate, ultimately leading to a heartfelt conversation about their intentions.

Example 2: The Group Project

In this example, we find two college friends, Mia and Sam, in a heated discussion about their mutual friend, Tom, who isn’t contributing equally to their group project. This situation highlights the complexities of teamwork and the challenge of addressing interpersonal issues.

“Can you believe Tom hasn’t submitted his part yet?” Mia exclaimed, pacing back and forth in their dorm room. “This is due in two days, and I feel like I’m doing all the work!”

Sam, seated at the desk, looked up from his laptop. “I know it’s frustrating, but maybe he’s just overwhelmed with other classes. We should give him a chance to explain himself.”

Mia stopped and turned to face Sam. “That’s the problem! We keep giving him chances, and nothing changes. It feels unfair to the rest of us who are working hard.”

Sam frowned, sensing the tension. “But we can’t just write him off. He’s our friend, and maybe he needs our support right now. What if we talk to him together?”

Mia shook her head, her frustration palpable. “I just don’t want to carry the whole project. It’s not about writing him off; it’s about holding him accountable!”

This exchange demonstrates how conflicts can arise in friendships when responsibilities are unevenly shared, leading to a deeper conversation about friendship and accountability.

Example 3: The Social Circle

In this scenario, two childhood friends, Emma and Liam, are discussing their mutual friend, Grace, who has recently started hanging out with a different group. This disagreement reveals their feelings about loyalty and change in friendships, making it a poignant moment.

“Did you see Grace’s latest Instagram post? She’s hanging out with those new friends again,” Emma said, her tone a mix of disbelief and concern. “I feel like she’s forgetting us.”

Liam leaned against the wall, a thoughtful expression crossing his face. “I get that it feels weird, but she’s allowed to expand her social circle. We can’t expect her to only spend time with us.”

Emma shook her head, frustration bubbling to the surface. “But it feels like she’s choosing them over us! What if she forgets about our friendship? We’ve been best friends forever!”

Liam sighed, taking a moment to gather his thoughts. “I don’t think it’s about choosing one group over another. Maybe we should reach out to her and see how she’s feeling. She might just be exploring new things.”

Emma crossed her arms, still worried. “I just don’t want to lose her. It’s like we’re being replaced.”

This conversation highlights the emotional complexities of friendships as they evolve, drawing attention to the importance of communication and understanding in maintaining relationships.

These examples of two friends having a disagreement about a mutual friend can serve as creative writing prompts, encouraging exploration of the dynamics of friendship and conflict resolution.